- The IEA now sees an oil surplus this quarter—the first since the war began. Q4 supply is forecast to exceed demand by 1.7m bpd. Last month's outlook showed a deficit.
- But the inventory build is entirely at sea. Floating stocks rose by 86m barrels in October; onshore inventories are at their lowest since at least 2016.
- Refined fuels, especially diesel, remain tight. Middle East product exports are about half their prewar level. Diesel trades at a premium of more than $60/bbl to crude.
- Korean pump prices have fallen for 26 straight weeks—but by less than KRW 1/L a week. A cap on refiners' wholesale prices muted the rally and is now muting the decline.
- Watch three things: Whether oil moves from ships to storage tanks, diesel shortages ease, and Korea changes its price caps, compensation rules or fuel taxes.
Hover over dotted terms—or tap on mobile—for definitions. Red dotsmark key concepts.
On October 30, U.S. WTI crude (WTI) traded at $104.12/bbl. By November 13 it was $88.56, a 15% decline.1, 2
In between, the International Energy Agency (IEA) changed its outlook. Its November 13 report projected that oil supply would exceed demand starting this quarter—the first such call since the Iran war began in late February.3
Yet Korean gasoline still averages KRW 1,855/L and has stayed above KRW 1,800 for 19 weeks since mid-July.4, 5 So why haven't pump prices fallen?
Two distinctions explain the gap.
First, crude is not refined fuel. The IEA sees a surplus in the broader oil market, while products such as diesel remain tight (Sections 01–03).
Second, global crude prices are not Korean pump prices. Wholesale price caps and fuel taxes sit between them (Sections 04–06).
From Deficit to Surplus:
The IEA Moved Up the Start Date
The IEA had projected a large 2027 surplus since June. The change is timing: it now sees the surplus beginning in Q4 2026.
| IEA outlook | Prior month | Nov 13 update |
|---|---|---|
| Q4 2026 | Supply deficit | +1.7m bpd surplusSupply: 105.0m bpd · Raised by 3.3m |
| 2026 demand | −2.6m bpd | −2.7m bpdTotal: 102.3m bpd |
| 2027 surplus | 3.94m bpd | ~3.8m bpdIranian output forecast cut |
Units: barrels per day · Sources: IEA November Oil Market Report, Reuters, S&P Global3, 6, 7
and Overtook DemandSolid line: actual Aug–Oct supply. Dashed line: IEA's projected Q4 average demand.
Sources: S&P Global and Reuters, citing IEA's November report3, 7 · The lines cover different periods; do not interpret the gap as a monthly surplus. Q4 averages: 105.0m bpd supply versus 103.3m demand.
Why Did Supply Recover So Fast?
- Gulf producers found alternative routes. OPEC data put October OPEC+ crude output at 41.23m bpd, 97% of its prewar February level.3 Hana Securities attributes roughly 90% of October's supply gain to Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Kuwait. Routes include ship-to-ship transfers near Hormuz, Saudi ports on the Red Sea, and northern Iraq's pipelines via Türkiye and Syria.8 Some vessels also transit the strait with tracking turned off—so-called dark crossings.3
- Supply also grew outside the Gulf. Output from the U.S., Canada, Brazil, Argentina and Guyana is expected to rise by a combined 1.6m bpd this year.3
- Demand weakened. High prices curbed consumption. The IEA expects demand to recover around March 2027, but full-year consumption of 104.3m bpd would still be 670,000 bpd below 2025.7
In its June report, the IEA forecast an 8m bpd supply increase in 2027 against just 2m bpd of demand growth.9 The prospect of a surplus was already in place.
The Inventory Build
Is Still at Sea
An oil surplus suggests overflowing storage tanks. October's data tell a different story.
OECD Industry Stocks −41mOctober inventory change, in barrels · IEA
Source: S&P Global, citing IEA's November report7 · These measures have different scopes and cannot simply be added.
- Floating stocks are at a January high; onshore stocks at a post-2016 low. Floating inventories reached 2.03bn barrels, including both crude and refined products. Global observed stocks rose for the first time since June, but onshore inventories remained at their lowest since at least 2016.7, 10
- Oil takes time to reach storage tanks. As Gulf exports recover, barrels in transit rise first. They become onshore stocks only after delivery and unloading.
- Prices move before inventories do. Dated Brent was $136/bbl in early October. By the time of the IEA report, it was around $93, down 32%.10
A surplus does not mean oil is already flooding the market. Crude prices have moved ahead of expected supply growth, while onshore storage remains depleted.
Refined Fuel Is Still Scarce
Recovering crude flows do not solve a shortage of refining capacity or product exports. Diesel is the tightest market.
Above Dubai CrudeSecond week of November · Average $/bbl · Korea National Oil Corp.
Source: Korea Economic Daily, citing Opinet weekly prices4
- Middle East product exports remain depressed. IEA says refined-product and LPG exports are about half prewar levels.7 September refined-product shipments were 1.9m bpd, or 40% of the prewar 4.7m, according to IEA data cited by Hana Securities.11
- Diesel and jet/kerosene are much tighter than gasoline. In Fig. 3, gasoline trades only $14/bbl above crude, versus $62 for diesel. iM Securities puts the kerosene crack at $59.7/bbl.12 Hana Securities estimates the broader refining margin at $36.3/bbl.8
- Emergency stocks are filling part of the gap. IEA member countries plan to release emergency oil reserves totaling 71m barrels by end-February 2027, including 15m barrels of diesel.3
Will Diesel Loosen in 2027? Evidence Cuts Both Ways
- Net new global refining capacity is forecast at just 770,000 bpd in 2027, below typical demand growth of 800,000–1m bpd (IEA via Hana Securities).11
- Russian refining assets hit by attacks since late October have capacity of 2.2m bpd—about 30% of the national total (Reuters via Hana Securities).11
- Hana Securities expects product shortages to persist in 2027.11
- The IEA expects refinery runs to rise 2.5m bpd in 2027 to 84.3m bpd.10
- iM Securities expects geopolitical risk and oil prices to ease. The U.S. EIA forecast it cites sees 2027 Brent crude down 12% and diesel down 7.4%.12
- Lower prices should revive demand. Nearly 80% of next year's demand growth is expected in petrochemical feedstocks such as LPG, ethane and naphtha .7
The 770,000 and 2.5m bpd forecasts measure different things: new refining capacity versus actual refinery throughput. Runs can recover as idled facilities restart. The key variable is the pace of repairs in Russia and the Middle East. Research No. 10 covers the diesel bottleneck.
Asia's Crude Premium
Has Almost Disappeared
After the war, Middle Eastern crude cost Korean buyers far more than U.S. grades. As Gulf exports recovered, that premium narrowed.
| Date / basis | Dubai minus WTI | Implication |
|---|---|---|
| March | +$39.2/bbl | Gulf supply disruptions made Asian crude much more expensive. |
| Nov 13 | +$3.5/bbl | Gulf exports recovered. |
| After Saudi discount (illustrative) | −$1.5/bbl | Applying Saudi Arabia's November OSP discount of $5/bbl puts the indicative price below WTI. |
Per barrel · Source: Hana Securities8
- Dubai is Asia's crude benchmark. Most crude imported by Korean refiners is priced against it. The wider the Dubai crude premium over WTI, the greater the cost disadvantage for Asian refiners.
- Hana Securities expects the advantage to flip. It projects that Asian refiners could secure the world's cheapest crude imports in 2027.8
- Supply security has improved. Korea's industry ministry says it has secured more than 90% of the country's average 2025 crude import volume for November–December.13
The −$1.5 figure is a benchmark comparison after an illustrative discount. It does not mean the landed cost of Saudi crude in Korea—including quality, freight and insurance—is $1.5/bbl below U.S. crude.
Cheaper crude still needs two links to reach the pump: the product shortages discussed in Section 03 and Korea's wholesale price cap.
Why Are Pump Prices
Barely Moving?
Korean fuel prices rose far less than U.S. prices during the war. Japan used subsidies; Korea used wholesale caps and tax relief. Those same measures are now muting the decline.
| Change from prewar prices | Gasoline | Diesel |
|---|---|---|
| South Korea | +9.60% | +15.28% |
| Japan | +8.32% | +10.67% |
| United States | +34.54% | +64.16% |
Source: South Korea's industry ministry, Nov 10 briefing (Yonhap)13
Two Policy Brakes
- Maximum wholesale price. This caps the price refiners charge fuel stations—not the retail pump price. Round 12, effective Nov 14 through Dec 11, fixes gasoline at KRW 1,784/L, diesel at KRW 1,773/L and kerosene at KRW 1,380/L. It is the fifth consecutive freeze.14, 15
- Fuel-tax cuts. Extended through Jan 31, 2027: 15% off gasoline (KRW 122/L) and 25% off diesel (KRW 145/L).16
The Cap Applies in the MiddleSecond week of November · International $/bbl; domestic KRW/L
- 1International benchmarkDubai crude 89 · Diesel 151 (Fig. 3)Sets refiners' feedstock costs and export values
- 2Refiner-to-station priceCaps: gasoline 1,784 · diesel 1,773Wholesale cap applies here (through Dec 11)
- 3Retail pump priceAverages: gasoline 1,855 · diesel 1,842Retailers add distribution costs and margins
Sources: Korea Economic Daily (Opinet and KNOC prices); Aju Business Daily (caps)4, 14
Retail stations buy fuel at regulated wholesale prices and add selling costs. Average pump prices thus exceed the cap by KRW 71/L for gasoline and KRW 69/L for diesel. Those spreads cover distribution and retail costs; they are not station profits.
The government notes that global crude remains more than $20/bbl above its late-June level, when the caps were set.14 But crude alone cannot reveal how much uncapped refiner prices would exceed the limits. FX rates, product benchmarks and pricing lags also matter.
The mechanism is straightforward: as long as the market price remains above the cap, falling crude has limited scope to lower actual wholesale prices. Pump prices therefore respond more slowly.
- Retail prices can fall more meaningfully once the cap ceases to bind. Either market prices must drop below it or the government must lower it. Global prices also typically reach Korean pumps with a two-to-three-week lag; inventories and selling costs vary by station.4
- What 26 consecutive weeks of "declines" really means. In the second week of November, gasoline fell KRW 0.4/L and diesel KRW 0.2/L. Weekly gasoline declines have been below KRW 1/L since the third week of September.4
Government vs. Refiners: The Dispute
The issue is how to value losses caused by the cap—and who pays.
- Crude prices have fallen, but remain elevated; shipping costs are also much higher.
- The cap is meant to cushion consumers.
- Refiners' compensation claims are assessed under cost-based government guidelines.
- The initial claims reviewed so far can be covered within the contingency reserve .
- Losses should be reimbursed against Singapore product benchmarks, not costs.
- Those benchmarks represent what refiners could have earned by exporting. The higher the refining margin, the wider the gap versus cost-based reimbursement.
- Compensation needed exceeds the contingency reserve.
Sources: Aju Business Daily, Metro Newspaper, Financial News14, 17, 18 · The second refiner-side point explains the difference between the two valuation methods.
Compensation by Supply Period
Funding differs by the period in which fuel was supplied.
| Supply period | Funding | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Mar 13–Jun 30 (first settlement) | KRW 4.2tn in contingency reservesGovernment: sufficient for this round | Result in early Dec; paid by year-end if uncontested |
| Jul–Sep | Same contingency reserve | Whether funding is sufficient remains unknown |
| Oct–Dec | KRW 1.449tn in the 2027 draft budget | Parliamentary budget review |
| 2027 | No allocation in government's draft; lawmakers discussing an increaseAdditional funding estimated at ~KRW 2tn | Policy extension, duration and funding are undecided. Government: "No decision." One official: "Keep it briefly, at least." |
Sources: AsiaToday, Metro Newspaper, News1, Financial News17, 18, 19, 20
The government has cited an end to the war, normal passage through Hormuz and oil prices in the $90s among possible exit conditions.14
How to Read Refiners' Earnings
- Separate global margins from domestic selling prices. High international refining margins do not remove Korea's domestic wholesale cap.
- Compensation recognition and cash payment need not coincide. Claims are assessed, can be appealed, and are then paid. Profit and cash flow may diverge; consult each refiner's filings for the accounting treatment.
Lower Oil Prices Do Not Immediately
Reset the Interest-Rate Outlook
- U.S. inflation remains sticky outside energy. According to Yuanta Securities, energy inflation eased but October core CPI rose about 0.3% m/m for a third straight month. Diesel shortages also slow overall fuel-price relief.21
- In Korea, caps intercept the inflation shock. Yuanta argues that fiscal spending, rather than consumer prices, has absorbed much of the oil shock. It estimates that removing the cap at current prices would add 0.7 percentage points of inflation pressure, falling as oil prices decline.21
- Relief from lower crude is conditional. If cheaper crude lowers refiner costs and domestic fuel prices, it could reduce both the inflation impact of lifting the cap and government reimbursement costs. Persistent diesel premiums or freight costs would limit those gains. As Fig. 3 shows, diesel is still far more expensive than crude.
Research No. 20 examined oil's role in the Fed rate outlook. The Bank of Korea's next policy decision is November 26.
Three Risks to the Outlook
There were 36 attacks on commercial vessels in Gulf waters in October, the highest monthly tally since the war began.2 Conflicting claims also emerged over the weekend (table below). Brent crude was little changed at about $94 late on November 16 KST, versus $95.84 at the November 13 settlement.1, 2
Iran's parliamentary speaker said seven conditions were conveyed through Qatar and that Tehran awaited a formal U.S. reply.22 On November 12, the U.S. president wrote, "We don't need a deal with Iran."2 A deal could expand crude availability; failure would test the alternative routes described in Section 01.
| Date | Iranian IRGC claim | Other side / verification |
|---|---|---|
| 11.13 | Destroyed a U.S. early-warning radar in Bahrain | U.S. military: shot down two drones; no damage |
| 11.14 | Two tankers struck mines in Hormuz | No independent confirmation reported |
| 11.15 | Drone attack on U.S. radar in Bahrain | Bahrain's military: aerial attack intercepted |
Source: Al Jazeera22
Key Dates Ahead
- 11.19 04:00October FOMC minutesKorea Standard Time
- 11.26Bank of Korea policy meetingPolicy rate decision
- 11.29OPEC+ meeting2027 production policy (reported)
- Early DecFirst refiner compensation assessmentMar 13–Jun 30 supply · Paid in 2026 if uncontested
- 12.11Round 12 wholesale cap expiresWill Round 13 be extended or reset?
- Mid-DecIEA December reportDid floating oil reach onshore tanks?
- 2027.1.31Scheduled expiry of fuel-tax cuts
- End-Feb 2027IEA emergency-stock release endsIncludes 15m barrels of diesel
Sources: Federal Reserve Board, Bizwatch, OPEC, FinanceFeeds, Aju Business Daily, AsiaToday, Yonhap, Reuters3, 14, 16, 19, 23, 24, 25, 26
- The IEA moved its Q4 balance forecast from deficit to surplus.
- October's observed inventory increase was offshore; onshore stocks hit a post-2016 low.
- Round 12 price caps held; fuel-tax cuts run through January 2027.
- IEA projects a 2027 surplus of about 3.8m bpd.
- Hana Securities expects Asia to have the cheapest crude import costs.
- iM Securities believes oil prices have peaked.
- When floating barrels will reach onshore inventories
- Compensation amounts and formula, plus 2027 funding
- Whether wholesale caps will continue in 2027