How K-Content
Makes Money
Now
Why record revenue failed to lift entertainment stocks.
Concerts, merchandise, new acts—and tourist spending.
Combined revenue at Korea's four major entertainment agencies hit a record in January–September. Yet by Nov. 17, their shares were down 36–53% from the start of the year. Most of the revenue growth came from one company, while both the business model and its biggest earners are changing. Foreign arrivals also topped 20 million for the first time—but visitors now spend their money differently.
Snowshagal ResearchAs of the Nov. 19, 2026 close (KST) · Market closed at 4:30 p.m. for the national college entrance exam15-minute main read · 20 minutes including expanded analysis
THREE QUESTIONS, THREE ANSWERS
- Q1Why did shares fall despite record revenue?One company produced 91% of the revenue increase, but its operating profit barely translated into bottom-line earnings. Investors cut valuations while waiting to see who could sustain earnings after the current world tour.01 Record Revenue · 02 Falling Shares →
- Q2Where does revenue come from now? Can it last?Concerts and merchandise. Live shows generate substantial revenue but thinner margins; merchandise can help support profits. The test is whether acts three or four years into their careers can fill larger venues.03 Live & Merch · 04 Newer Acts · 05 Overseas Markets →
- Q3Where do 20 million visitors spend their money?Duty-free spending per buyer is falling. Spending is growing at beauty retailers, convenience stores, hotels and clinics. It is not yet clear whether the same spending has simply shifted between sectors.06 Tourist Spending · 07 Regulation →
Shares Surged.
Earnings Hadn't Changed.
Hover over underlined terms for definitions, or tap on mobile. Red dotted lines flag key concepts. Select a + panel to expand the analysis.
On Nov. 18, at a summit in Shenzhen, South Korea and China announced the substantial conclusion of follow-up FTA talks on services and investmentafter eight years and eight months of negotiations.1 Entertainment stocks moved twice that day.
- Regular session Shares rose on reports that the two countries were discussing cultural exchanges. SM closed up 14%.2
- After the close Details of the FTA outcome were reported only after the regular session ended. In the subsequent after-hours marketSM hit its daily price limit.
- Concerts Were Not Included The announcement covered proposed market access for films, games, television co-productions and travel agencies. It did not authorize K-pop concerts in mainland China. Lifting theunofficial Chinese restrictions on Korean entertainment remains a market hope, not a confirmed policy change. See Section 05 for details.1, 4
- A Second Headline After the bell, HYBE also disclosed plans to acquire 50.1% of Japanese entertainment company KeyHolder for about ₩105.7bn.5 The after-hours move in HYBE also reflected this news. Its contribution cannot be separated from the FTA announcement.
- What Matters Nothing changed in these companies' earnings overnight. Expectations for future earnings changed.
The session captured the contradiction in K-pop equities: record revenue, but shares down an average 43% year-to-date as of the previous close. HYBE had lost more than half its value. In this sector, investors price the next act, not just the latest quarter.
The rally continued Nov. 19. HYBE gained another 14% and SM 8% in the regular session, which ended at 4:30 p.m. because of the college entrance exam.3 Reports that day said the government had opened further channels for discussing concert permits with China (Section 05).
Six days earlier, on Nov. 12, South Korea welcomed its 20 millionth foreign visitor of the year—a first.6 K-content was the most-cited reason for considering a trip to Korea.7 While markets fixated on semiconductors, K-content was producing both records and steep share-price losses.
What This Report Covers
- Sections 01–02 How much did revenue rise? How much became profit? Why did stocks fall?
- Sections 03–05 How the revenue model shifts from albums to live shows and merchandise, how newer acts replace established ones, and how export markets shift from Japan toward the U.S. and China.
- Sections 06–07 · Extended Analysis The same principle applies to tourism: rising visitor numbers and sales do not guarantee profits for every business. Where does tourist spending land, and how does regulation affect what companies retain?
This is an analysis of the numbers, not a recommendation to buy or sell a stock.
Record Revenue and Exports.
Album Sales Rebound.
Start with the good news. Combined revenue at the four agencies hit a record, as did physical-album exports. Domestic album sales also rebounded after two straight years of declines.
- Four-Agency Revenue HYBE, SM, JYP and YG generated a record ₩5.662tn in revenue in January–September, up 50.9% y/y. Operating profit rose 32.6% to ₩446.3bn (Kiwoom Securities).8 Revenue for the third quarter alone reached ₩2.241tn.9
- Operating Profit Still Below 2023 The four agencies earned ₩446.3bn in operating profit through September, 16% below the ₩528.7bn reported for the same period in 2023.10 Exclude HYBE's roughly ₩255bn one-off share-based compensation charge, and the figure approaches ₩700bn—above 2023 (our calculation). Revenue hit a record; reported operating profit did not.
- HYBE's Record Quarter HYBE reported its highest quarterly revenue, ₩1.526tn in Q3. Nine-month sales reached ₩3.674tn, putting ₩4tn in annual revenue within reach.11
- Physical Album Sales Domestic album sales reached 85.1m units in January–October, up 11.7%. After two consecutive annual declines, sales are on track to top 100m for the first time in three years (based onCircle Chart data, as cited by Kiwoom Securities).8, 12
- Album Exports Exports grew 57.5% to more than $400m in the first ten months, already exceeding the full-year 2025 figure (Korea Customs Service data via Kiwoom).8
| Third quarter 2026 | Revenue (₩100m) | Y/y change | Operating profit (₩100m) | Y/y change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HYBE | 15,257 | +109.8% | 1,885 | Turned profitable (vs. −422 a year ago) |
| SM Entertainment | 2,911 | −9.5% | 355 | −26.4% |
| JYP Ent. | 2,675 | +15.0% | 480 | +17.6% |
| YG | 1,567 | −9.4% | 135 | −56.8% |
| Four-agency total | 22,410 | +54.1% | 2,855 | Roughly 3.7× the prior-year 779 |
Revenue Soared.
Why Did Stocks Fall?
By Nov. 17, all four stocks were down 36–53% from the start of the year, while the KOSPI had gained 18%. Why the disconnect?
On wider screens, the lines show monthly trends.
- How Far Did They Fall? As of Nov. 17: HYBE −53%, SM −43%, JYP −41%, YG −36%.3 Their combined market value shrank from ₩24.1tn on Feb. 19 to ₩10.9tn by mid-November (Kiwoom Securities).8
- The Valuation Multiple Fell, Too Share prices reflect earnings multiplied by what investors will pay for them. The four agencies' average 12-month forward P/Efell from 24.3× at the start of the year to 15× in November—more than one-third below their five-year average of 23.4× (Kiwoom Securities).8 A falling multiple despite stable or rising earnings is called de-rating.
- Trading Dried Up Average daily trading value across the four stocks fell from ₩270bn in January to ₩51bn in September. Market attention and capital shifted to semiconductors (Kiwoom Securities).8
The Aggregate Masks the Story
Most revenue growth came from one agency and, at its center, one group's tour. Investors are already pricing what happens after that tour.
Slower Growth
The premium investors paid for fast growth has faded. Profit growth at the other three agencies has slowed sharply (Yuanta Securities).
Hit Shows Cannot Be Forecast
Before tour dates are released, next year's ticket revenue is hard to estimate. Announcements often move prices more than quarterly earnings (Kiwoom Securities).
REASON 1 · THE GROUP-TOTAL ILLUSION
The four agencies did post record revenue. But splitting the increase by company tells a different story.
- Other three agencies Excluding HYBE, nine-month revenue was ₩1.988tn (+9.3%) and operating profit ₩283.3bn (−2.5%). Kiwoom argues that merchandise growth (+20%) merely filled the gap left by established acts finishing their tours.8
- One Company's Record, One Tour BTS's world tour drove HYBE's revenue surge, drawing roughly 70,000 people per show (Kiwoom Securities).8 Next year's results will be compared against quarters that included that tour.
ONE MORE NUMBERRecord Operating Profit, Minimal Earnings for Shareholders
- Third quarter HYBE reported record operating profit of ₩188.5bn in Q3, but net income was just ₩11.3bn—down 90% q/q. Non-operating items produced a net loss of ₩148.6bn, which the company said was largely a paper loss from revaluing foreign-currency cash as the won strengthened.15 Net income attributable to parent shareholders was a loss of ₩6.8bn.16
- January–September Operating profit was ₩162.9bn, alongside a ₩35.6bn net loss and a ₩63bn loss attributable to parent shareholders. The results include about ₩255bn in one-off share-based compensation expense. The controlling shareholder transferred existing shares to the company, which held them as treasury shares before distributing them to employees. Their value was recognized as an expense.17, 18 No cash left the company, and no new shares were issued. HYBE separately reported adjusted nine-month operating profit of ₩417.9bn, excluding that expense.16 Reported profit and profit excluding one-offs tell different stories.
- Share Price The day after the results, Nov. 4, HYBE shares fell 11.5% to a 52-week low.3, 19 The net-income figure alone cannot explain the full decline.
An FX revaluation loss does not mean operations deteriorated; it could reverse if exchange rates turn. But equity holders also care about the profit attributable to them. Focusing on revenue and operating profit misses that distinction.
Show the Math · Who Generated the Incremental Revenue?Why our figures differ from Kiwoom's 96% claim · Company breakdown
Kiwoom wrote that HYBE accounted for 96% of the increase. Recalculating from the company-level figures in the same report gives 91% of revenue growth and more than 100% of operating-profit growth. This report uses our recalculation.
| Jan–Sep revenue (₩100m) | 2026 | Growth rate | Increase |
|---|---|---|---|
| HYBE | 36,740 | +90.0% | +17,403 |
| SM Entertainment | 9,200 | +7.5% | +642 |
| JYP Ent. | 6,370 | +8.0% | +472 |
| YG | 4,316 | +15.5% | +579 |
| Four-agency total | 56,626 | +50.9% | +19,096 |
| Jan–Sep operating profit (₩100m) | 2026 | Growth rate | Increase |
|---|---|---|---|
| HYBE | 1,630 | +254.3% | +1,170 |
| SM Entertainment | 1,270 | −1.1% | −14 |
| JYP Ent. | 1,120 | −0.8% | −9 |
| YG | 438 | −10.5% | −51 |
| Four-agency total | 4,458 | +32.6% | +1,096 |
We back-calculated prior-year figures using 2026 values and reported growth rates. The results may differ by roughly ₩1bn because the source rounds company figures to ₩1bn. The resulting totals (₩5.6626tn revenue, ₩445.8bn operating profit) differ slightly from Kiwoom's four-agency totals (₩5.662tn and ₩446.3bn). HYBE disclosed nine-month operating profit of ₩162.9bn, implying growth of roughly 260%, versus 254.3% in Kiwoom's table. This table and Figure 02-3 retain Kiwoom's figures. Revenue: ₩1.7403tn ÷ ₩1.9096tn = 91%. HYBE added ₩117bn in operating profit while the other three lost ₩7.4bn, yielding a ₩109.6bn net increase. For Q3 alone, HYBE added ₩798.5bn of the group's ₩786.5bn increase; the other three declined by ₩12bn.9 HYBE's and YG's nine-month figures match reports citing their earnings disclosures.11, 14
REASON 2 · GROWTH SLOWED
Fast-growing companies command higher multiples. That helped entertainment stocks trade above 20× earnings. When growth slows, the multiple is often the first thing to fall.
- Profit Growth at the Other Three Operating-profit growth at SM, JYP and YG slowed from more than 40% annually during 2020–2023 to low single digits from 2024 onward (Yuanta Securities).13
- The Seven-Year Clock The standard exclusive artist contract lasts seven years. Afterward, the agency's share of revenue may shrink, or renewal may fail. Investors assign less lasting value to profits concentrated in veteran groups (Kiwoom Securities).8
REASON 3 · HITS CANNOT BE FORECAST
- An Industry Without an Order Backlog Shipbuilders and defense contractors can estimate next year's revenue from signed orders. Music agencies cannot count concertgoers until tour schedules are announced.
- Earnings Forecasts Follow Tour Announcements Kiwoom describes entertainment as an industry where hit-making cannot be assumed. It argues that a world-tour announcement—not quarterly earnings—restored the sector's multiple after it fell to 15× in 2024.8
- The Same Pattern on Nov. 18–19 News, not new earnings figures, moved the stocks.
The Outlook Varies Widely by Company
| Company | Share Price YTD change | Q3 operating profit Y/y change | 2027 operating profit Forecast growth | 12-month forward P/E |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HYBE | −53% | Turned profitable | +59%Kiwoom +99% | 18.2× |
| SM Entertainment | −43% | −26% | +18%Kiwoom +38% | 12.0× |
| JYP Ent. | −41% | +18% | +5% | 11.9× |
| YG | −36% | −57% | +1% | 15.2× |
From Album Sales
to Concerts and Merch
Entertainment earnings once followed the album-release calendar. Concerts and merchandise now drive much of the top line.
- Live Shows and Merchandise Combined concert revenue across the four agencies reached ₩1.8095tn in January–September (+95%). Revenue from merchandise and licensingrose to ₩1.2227tn (+54%), versus growth of 32% for albums and recorded music (Kiwoom Securities).8
- Merch Grew Beyond Album Releases In Q3, merchandise revenue rose 23% at SM, 44% at YG and 47% at JYP.8, 20
- Every Concert Is a Storefront HYBE sold ₩107bn in merchandise on its North American tour in Q3 alone (Kiwoom Securities).8
A Larger Concert Mix Can Compress Margins
An individual concert may become more profitable as attendance rises. Yet a larger concert share can reduce an agency's overall profit margin. Here's a simple example using ₩100 in ticket revenue.
- In the Forecasts HYBE's gross marginis projected to fall from 47.4% in 2022 to 34.1% in 2026. Kiwoom cites concerts' rising share of revenue, from 14.5% to 39.7%, as the main driver.8
- Why Merchandise Matters Merchandise generally carries better margins than concerts. Combined merchandise and licensing revenue at the four agencies tripled from ₩351.4bn in 2020 to ₩1.0882tn in 2025 (Kiwoom Securities).8
- Sales Beyond Concert Venues Of the 426 pop-up stores opened by the four agencies over the past year, 77% were overseas (Kiwoom Securities).8
Albums Are Shifting From Listening to Collecting
- U.S. U.S. physical-music revenue rose 25.9% in the first half, far outpacing overall music-market growth of 6.9% (RIAA data cited by Kyobo Securities).21
- Albums as Collectibles Albums sold as keychains, cards and other merchandise-style formats made up 17.8% of sales among Circle Chart's top 400 albums, up from 11.3% in 2023.22
A New Generation
Takes the Stage
Established groups have generated most of the profits so far. Brokers expect younger acts to begin taking on a bigger role from 2027.
Entertainment agencies treat each act as an IP asset. Why does year four matter? Groups often make their first tours in years two and three, then graduate to venues holding more than 10,000 people in year four—a step-change in scale (Kiwoom Securities).8
| Debut | Act count | Fourth year |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 7 acts | 2027 |
| 2025 | 6 acts | 2028 |
| 2026 | About 6 acts | 2029 |
- New Groups, Bigger Stages Roughly 19 groups debuting in 2024–2026 are set to reach the large-venue phase over the next three years. The 13 acts from 2024–2025 hit year four in 2027–2028; the 2026 cohort follows in 2029 (Kiwoom Securities).8
- Starting From a Bigger Base Groups debuting in 2024 averaged 293,000 concertgoers by year three, 2.5× the 119,000 for the previous generation (Kiwoom Securities).8
- Already a Major Share of Albums This year, newer actsaccount for roughly 40% of album sales (Eugene Investment & Securities).23
- Streaming Audiences Are Growing Aggregate Spotify monthly listenersacross major acts at the four agencies total 248.95m, up 4.5%. Excluding the three largest acts, growth rises to 8.1% (Yuanta Securities).13
All Four Agencies Plan New Debuts in 2027
- An Unusual Year All four major agencies plan to launch new groups in 2027, which Hana Securities describes as highly unusual.24
- New Acts Cost Money First Development costs come before revenue. If a debut succeeds, album sales, merchandise and touring revenue follow in stages (Kiwoom Securities).8
- The Margin Opportunity Agencies generally retain a larger share early in an artist's contract. Kiwoom expects margins to improve as newer groups contribute more revenue.8, 13
Not Everyone Agrees on the Scale
| Broker | 2027 operating profit: four agencies | Y/y change | Investment view |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kiwoom Securities | ₩1.0125tn | +51.8% | First year of a profit handoff from veteran acts to newer ones. The removal of this year's one-off expenses also helps. |
| Yuanta Securities | ₩916.2bn | +32.6% | 2026 marks the profit trough; excluding HYBE, the other three shift from −9.1% this year to +9.8% next year. |
| DS Investment & Securities | No combined figure | Limited revenue growth, but better earnings quality. Focuses on the gap after the biggest acts. |
- The Concern DS Investment & Securities sums up this year's selloff as concern over what comes after the biggest groups.25
- More Acts Do Not Guarantee More Profit More newer groups are entering the pipeline. But their future earnings depend on concerts not yet staged. Three tests connect the two: (1) do venues get larger, (2) how many seats sell, and (3) how much profit remains per show? New-act development costs and the gap left by veteran groups must also be covered.
From Japan to China and the U.S.:
K-Pop Album Exports Shift
For years, Japan was the biggest overseas buyer of Korean physical albums. This year, China and the United States overtook it in export value.
| Share of exports | 2016 | Jan–Oct 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Japan | 45% | 19% |
| U.S. | 3% | 24% |
- U.S. Eight of the top ten CDs sold in the U.S. in the first half were K-pop albums (Kiwoom Securities).8 U.S. CD unit sales rose 16.0% in the first half; excluding K-pop, growth was just 6.7% (Kyobo Securities).21
- Europe Album exports to Germany rose 181% and to the U.K. 111% in January–September (Kyobo Securities).21
- Concert Audiences Are Expanding, Too Western markets' share of concert attendance at the four agencies rose from 20% in 2019 to 33% in 2026 (Kiwoom Securities).8
- Locally Cast Groups One localized group —formed with members recruited overseas and debuted in its home market—attracted 597,000 concertgoers in its third year. Two more such acts are expected to debut in the U.S. next year (Kiwoom Securities).8
- More Markets, More Room to Grow New acts can target different regions instead of competing for a fixed pool of fans, Kiwoom argues.8
Records and Merch Sell. The Concert Door Remains Shut.
China has effectively restricted the distribution of South Korean popular culture since around 2016. Business never stopped entirely: China now leads album exports, and SM opened a 335-square-meter official merchandise store in Shanghai on April 29.27 What remained restricted was large-scale concerts on the mainland. The key is what the Nov. 18 announcement promised—and what it did not.
- Most-favored-nation treatment for films and games, requiring treatment no less favorable than that given to other countries
- Non-discrimination in the screening and approval of films and online games, alongside MFN treatment. South Korea's trade ministry says China has not previously included these provisions in a trade agreement.
- Expanded co-production coverage from films to dramas, animation, variety shows and documentaries
- Under the planned agreement, South Korean travel agencies operating in 23 Chinese regions would be allowed to sell outbound tours to Chinese and foreign residents, including group trips, individual packages and multi-country itineraries via Japan or Southeast Asia.
- Permission for K-pop concerts in mainland China
- A separate provision on music or concerts
- Any declaration that the unofficial Hallyu restrictions have been lifted
- Final text and legal review
- Formal signing
- Steps toward entry into force; no date announced
- South Korean Government's Position The presidential office said Nov. 18, local time, that the agreement does not require either country to approve the other's artists for concerts. But it said more channels were now open for discussions that could lead to permits. Beijing treats large gatherings differently from films and games, so smaller shows might be an easier starting point.30
- China's Position On Nov. 19, China's Ministry of Commerce confirmed the substantial conclusion of negotiations, naming culture and internet services among the areas of cooperation. It made no mention of concerts. Remaining steps include technical finalization, translation, legal review and signature.31
- An Official “Lifting” May Never Be Declared China has never formally acknowledged the existence of the restrictions, making an official repeal announcement unlikely, according to SK Securities.28
- Concerts Would Still Take Time Tours are normally planned at least six months ahead. Even if permits are agreed next year, performances in China may not resume until 2028 or later, SK Securities forecasts.28 Daol Investment & Securities expects any earnings impact no earlier than the second half of 2027.32
- What a Reopening Would Mean There are two effects to separate. Existing album and merchandise sales could rise. More importantly, concerts would create ticket and on-site merchandise revenue that does not currently exist. The first effect is already reflected in reported sales; the second has yet to generate revenue from mainland-China shows. Investors are betting on the latter.
That covers the entertainment agencies. Sections 06–07 apply the same test to tourism. More visitors and higher revenue do not guarantee that every business keeps more profit.
20 Million Visitors.
A Shift in Spending.
K-pop agencies earn money when fans buy tickets and merchandise. Tourism works the same way: which companies benefit depends on where visitors actually spend.
- K-Content Tops Travel Motivations K-content was cited by 34.5% of respondents considering a visit to Korea, followed by traditional culture (32.5%) and proximity (26.5%), according to a Korea Culture & Tourism Institute survey.7 Respondents could select multiple reasons. The findings do not mean all 20 million visitors came because of K-content.
- Spending Outpaced Visitor Growth Foreign visitors spent ₩15.9416tn on cards in January–September, up 47.7%—more than twice the growth in arrivals (+21.5%).6 Average card spending per visitor rose from ₩767,000 to ₩932,000.33
- Concertgoers Spent More Foreign fans attending a major group's March concert at Gwanghwamun spent an average ₩3.53m each and stayed 8.7 days, according to a government survey. For the April Goyang show, the figures were ₩2.91m and 7.4 days. The average inbound visitor in Q1 spent ₩2.45m and stayed 6.1 days.34 Those figures come from specific large concerts, not a representative average for concert tourists.
- China Chinese arrivals reached 5.47m in the first nine months, up 29%.8 Women in their twenties and thirties accounted for 47% of the increase. A 2025 survey found that 95.3% of Chinese women in that age range traveled independently, not in organized tour groups (Kiwoom Securities).35
- Japan Moved the Other Way Amid China–Japan tensions, Chinese arrivals in Japan fell 55% to 3.34m in January–September (Kiwoom Securities).8 Some demand may have shifted to Korea, but the scale is unknown.
- Beyond Seoul Regional airports handled 3.24m foreign arrivals through September, up 37.4% and accounting for 19% of the total.6
Winners and Losers
Duty-free stores
Average spending per foreign duty-free buyer fell from ₩830,000 to ₩590,000.33 August spending was down 22.4% y/y.36 Average purchase value here means foreign-customer revenue divided by the number of buyers.
Department stores
Foreign-customer revenue at three major chains more than doubled in H1.33 The foreign-customer share of total sales fell in Q3 as the won strengthened (Hanwha Investment & Securities).37
Multi-brand beauty retailers
Based on Olive Young's offline revenue.33 Olive Young's foreign-customer sales rose 47% in January–August, while foreign sales at duty-free stores rose 3.2% in H1 (Kiwoom; periods differ).35
Convenience stores
Low-ticket items are less sensitive to exchange rates. Convenience-store networks also benefit as tourists venture beyond Seoul (Kiwoom Securities).38
Hotels
Few new five-star hotels have opened in Seoul. Limited room supply has kept rates rising even as a stronger won made Korea more expensive (Kiwoom Securities).8
Casinos
Casino drop—chips purchased—rose 6.1%. Jeju was up 28.7%, while an operator hit by fewer Chinese VIPs fell 2.2% (Yuanta Securities).39
Foreign-Visitor Medical Spending
Dermatology spending rose about 64% and pharmacy spending about 196%, while plastic surgery's share fell.40 Spending is broadening from retail shopping to skin care and cosmetic procedures (IBK Investment & Securities).41
A major explanation is the changing customer mix. Duty-free stores once relied heavily on Chinese bulk resellers known asdaigou. Today's independent travelers make smaller, more frequent purchases at beauty chains, convenience stores and dermatology clinics.33
- When the Won Strengthens Kiwoom argues that exchange rates affect tourist spending more than visitor counts. As travel becomes more expensive, visitors cut shopping and experiences first; accommodation spending is stickier (Korea Tourism Organization survey).8
- The Money Flows Both Ways As the won strengthened, South Koreans spent more in Japan. Their shopping expenditure there rose 66% to ¥78.3bn in Q3 (Hanwha Investment & Securities).37
- Cosmetics Exports to China Rebound Exports to China rose for five straight months from June, jumping 31.6% in October. Yet January–October exports were still only 35% of the 2021 level (Kiwoom Securities).35
- Related Research Cosmetics exports: see Investment Insight No.23; domestic department-store spending: see NO.38.
Expanded View · 2027 Visitor Forecast by OriginKiwoom forecast · China accounts for 40% of the expected increase
| Visitors (millions) | 2025 | 2026 Estimate | 2027 Forecast | Growth rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| China | 5.48 | 7.34 | 8.37 | +14% |
| Japan | 3.65 | 4.18 | 4.47 | +7% |
| Taiwan | 1.89 | 2.5 | 2.75 | +10% |
| Rest of Asia | 3.92 | 4.36 | 4.88 | +12% |
| Americas | 1.96 | 2.18 | 2.35 | +8% |
| Europe | 1.32 | 1.6 | 1.79 | +12% |
| Middle East & Oceania | 0.71 | 0.79 | 0.85 | +8% |
| Total | 18.93 | 22.95 | 25.46 | +11% |
Kiwoom assumes continued visa-free access for Chinese tour groups and more flights to regional airports. The 2025 base is reported as 18.93m or 18.94m, depending on the source. The Korea Tourism Organization aims to attract 26m visitors in 2027.8
REGULATORY WILDCARD
Casino Contributions to the Tourism Fund
Policy determines how much profit businesses retain from the same revenue. Casino contributions to Korea's tourism fund illustrate the risk. Here are the proposals and dates—not a prediction.
Foreigner-only casinos pay a share of revenue into the Tourism Promotion and Development Fund. The levy uses progressive revenue brackets. In July, the government outlined a plan to raise the statutory ceiling.42, 43
| Current rules | Progressive rates: 1% on annual revenue up to ₩1bn; 5% on the portion between ₩1bn and ₩10bn; 10% on revenue above ₩10bn. |
| Proposed change | Raise the statutory ceiling from 10% to 15%. The Culture Ministry says any higher rate would apply only to revenue above a new top-tier threshold, not to all sales. |
| Not Yet Decided | The new high-revenue threshold and actual rate. They would be set in an enforcement decree after consultation with industry and experts. |
| Jeju Island | Jeju casinos operate under a separate law, the Jeju Special Act, which would require its own amendment. |
Government View · Culture Ministry
- Since the levy was introduced in 1995, foreigner-only casino revenue has increased 10.3×, while the contribution structure has remained largely unchanged for almost 30 years.
- The levy is not a tax, the ministry says. It funds tourism facilities, promotion and visitor acquisition.
- The proposed 15% would not apply across all revenue.44
Industry and Broker Concerns
The government is also discussing raising the departure levyembedded in airfares from ₩7,000 per person to ₩15,000–20,000 (Kiwoom Securities).8
THE 2027 WATCHLIST
Nine Indicators
The list runs from entertainment to tourism. The middle column shows the current position; the right explains why it matters. These are not forecasts.
| Indicator | Current | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 · Tour announcements | Only some 2027 dates have been disclosed for newer acts. | First sign of monetization: track venue size and ticket sell-through. |
| 2 · Early results from new acts | All four agencies plan debuts in 2027. | Watch streaming-chart performance and first venue size, not just album units. |
| 3 · Merchandise revenue | Up 54% through September, outpacing albums. | Can merch offset thinner concert margins? |
| 4 · Operating vs. net profit | HYBE posted a nine-month net loss. | Do non-operating currency effects fade and profits reach parent shareholders? |
| 5 · Album exports by destination | China and the U.S. overtook Japan. | Does the geographic buyer base keep broadening? |
| 6 · FTA follow-up with China | Negotiations substantially concluded; signing and entry into force still pending. Concerts under separate discussion. | Do specific measures on concert permits follow? |
| 7 · Tourist spending per person | January–September card spending of about ₩930,000 per visitor. | Spending matters more than raw arrivals. |
| 8 · Duty-free spending per buyer | Down 29% from January. | Does it recover with a return of Chinese group tours? |
| 9 · Casino-fund regulations | Only a proposed 15% ceiling so far. | Watch for the revenue brackets and actual rates. |
What Is Known, Forecast and Still Unknown
KNOWNConfirmed Facts
- One company supplied 91% of four-agency revenue growth.
- That company's nine-month earnings attributable to parent shareholders were negative.
- Concerts and merchandise grew faster than albums.
- The China–Korea FTA announcement contained no concert provision.
ESTIMATEBroker Estimates and Forecasts
- 2027 four-agency operating profit of ₩916.2bn–₩1.0125tn (Yuanta–Kiwoom); company-level growth of +1% to +59% (Yuanta).
- 2028 concert attendance of 5.44m for acts debuting from 2021 (Kiwoom).
- If Chinese concerts are permitted, Hana models average 2027 operating-profit growth of 36% across the four agencies, ranging from 22% to 99% by company. Its illustration assumes eight acts stage 25 dome concerts a year. China has not yet permitted Korean acts to use dome-size venues, so this is strictly hypothetical.
- Earliest possible China-related earnings impact: H2 2027 (Daol). Actual concerts may not return until 2028 or later (SK).
- 2027 foreign arrivals: 25.46m (Kiwoom).
- Casino-levy impact: −8% to −24% on operating profit, depending on assumptions (iM–Kiwoom; −24% is the worst case).
UNKNOWNStill Unknown
- When and to what extent K-pop concerts can return to mainland China.
- Whether next year's debut acts will succeed.
- The casino levy thresholds and rates.
- Per-visitor spending if the won stays strong.
Record Revenue. Falling Stocks.
What Happened in Between?
The disconnect is clear. One company drove most of the revenue increase. Concerts became a bigger revenue stream but brought thinner margins. The next generation of profitable acts has yet to fill major venues. Tourism tells a parallel story: record visitor numbers, but a different mix of businesses capturing the spending.
The Nov. 18–19 rally again showed how quickly news can move this sector ahead of earnings. It has happened before. Around the 2017 South Korea–China summit and presidential visit, entertainment-agency market caps rose by as much as 41%, but tours in China never reopened (Hana Securities).29 Expectations also reversed after last November's APEC meeting and a visit to China this January (SK Securities).28 The Tests for 2027 Tour schedules and venue sizes for newer acts; merchandise revenue; whether operating profits reach shareholders; and concrete follow-up announcements from China.
Related Reading
Glossary
- IP (intellectual property)
- In entertainment, “IP” often refers to an artist or group itself. Albums, tours and merchandise all earn revenue under that identity.
- MD (merchandise)
- Fan goods such as light sticks, clothing, dolls and photocards, sold at venues, pop-up stores and online.
- newer acts
- An artist or group early in its career—generally no more than seven years since debut in this report. Veteran or established acts are the opposite.
- 12-month forward P/E
- Share price divided by estimated earnings per share over the coming 12 months. Measures how many times expected earnings investors pay.
- de-rating
- A decline in the valuation multiple (P/E) even when earnings hold steady or rise. The reverse is re-rating.
- gross margin
- Gross profit divided by revenue, after direct costs. Concerts often have lower gross margins because production and artist payouts are substantial.
- unofficial Chinese restrictions on Korean entertainment
- The unofficial restrictions China has effectively imposed on Korean dramas, films and concerts since around 2016. Beijing has never formally announced such a policy.
- Casino drop
- The amount casino customers spend buying chips. Net gaming revenue reflects the amount retained by the casino, determined in part by the hold rate.
- Average daily rate (ADR)
- Average room revenue per occupied room-night at a hotel.
- licensing
- Fees paid for using an act's name, likeness or characters on a third party's products.
- Circle Chart
- Korea's official music chart, operated by the Korea Music Content Association. Physical-album counts are based on shipments.
- pop-up stores
- A temporary retail location selling merchandise, often tied to an album release or tour.
- Spotify monthly listeners
- The number of people who listened to an artist on Spotify during a month.
- localized group
- A group recruited and debuted outside Korea, using a Korean agency's planning and training model.
- daigou
- Chinese resellers who buy goods in bulk from Korean duty-free stores to resell in China.
- Tourism Promotion and Development Fund
- A government fund used for tourism infrastructure, promotion and attracting visitors. Casino and departure levies are major funding sources.
- departure levy
- A charge included in airfare for travelers departing South Korea; proceeds go to the Tourism Promotion and Development Fund.
- after-hours market
- Trading on an alternative exchange after the regular market closes, through 8 p.m. Thin liquidity can produce large price moves.
- follow-up FTA talks on services and investment
- The 2015 South Korea–China FTA focused on goods. Separate talks to further open services and investment markets began in 2018.
Sources, Definitions and Data Differences
Methodology All dates are Korea time. Share-price moves use closing prices; “YTD” means versus the Dec. 30, 2025 close. The four agencies are HYBE, SM Entertainment, JYP Entertainment and YG Entertainment. Growth is y/y unless otherwise stated.
Verification Scope The original report checked Q3 results, visitor numbers, foreign-card spending and FTA terms against reports citing company filings and official government statements, as well as policy briefings. “Record” is used only where a broker or cited report used that description. Share-price moves were recalculated from Yahoo Finance closes. Nine-month earnings, album sales and exports rely on company filings, Circle Chart and Customs Service figures as reproduced by brokers. All forecasts and estimates are attributed to their originating brokers.
Differences Between Sources
- “96% of the increase” Kiwoom's wording. Recalculating from the same report's company figures gives 91% for revenue and more than 100% for operating profit. See the expandable calculations in Section 02.
- Share-Price Declines Kiwoom gives −37% to −53% (apparently as of Nov. 13), and Yuanta −37% to −56% (Nov. 12). This report recalculates from Nov. 17 and Nov. 18 closes. The KOSPI YTD return also varies by date, from +18% to +26%.
- Nov. 18 Price Moves Regular-session closes and after-hours quotes differ sharply. Figure IN-1 separates them. After-hours quotes are as of 7:30 p.m.
- Timeline on Nov. 18 Immediately after the close, market reports attributed the rally to news of cultural-exchange talks. Every report on the substantial conclusion of the FTA negotiations reviewed here appeared after the 3:30 p.m. market close; the earliest was at 3:44 p.m. The regular-session gains are therefore not attributed to the later announcement.
- “Record” Operating Profit Kiwoom also calls the four agencies' nine-month ₩446.3bn operating profit a record. This report uses “record” only for revenue because it did not independently compare the operating-profit figure with prior years. Nor does it call combined Q3 revenue a quarterly record, since the cited reporting did not.
- 2027 Operating-Profit Forecasts Kiwoom: ₩1.0125tn (+51.8%); Yuanta: ₩916.2bn (+32.6%). The brokers start from different 2026 estimates.
- Physical Album Sales Kiwoom reports 85.1m albums sold in January–October; media reports cite about 79m among Circle Chart's top 400 for January–September. Periods and universes differ. Figures for full-year 2023 also vary: 114.05m (Kiwoom) versus 115.77m (Korea Herald).
- Leading Destination for Album Exports The U.S. led in Q1 (reports citing the Customs Service). China led over January–October (Customs data reproduced by Kiwoom).
- Foreign-Visitor Spending The Culture Ministry's ₩15.9416tn (+47.7%) covers card spending in January–September. Kiwoom's tourism receipts estimate of ₩31.5tn (+36.7%) and ₩1.84m per visitor covers a broader scope.
- Visitor Growth +22% in January–August (Eugene Investment & Securities) versus +21.5% in January–September (Culture Ministry): different periods.
- Casino-Levy Impact Kiwoom's −24% assumes the 15% ceiling applies broadly to high-revenue operators. iM's −8% to −9% applies it only to revenue above ₩300bn annually.
- SM's Q3 Operating Profit Reports differ between ₩35.5bn and ₩35.7bn. This report uses ₩35.5bn.
- P/E Discount for the Four Agencies Kiwoom calls a 15× November P/E a 33% discount to the five-year average of 23.4×. The two figures imply about 36%, so this report says “more than one-third.”
- 2028 Attendance for Newer Acts Kiwoom's summary gives 5.49m for acts debuting after 2020; the detailed table gives 5.44m for 2028. This report uses the detailed annual series.
- Comparison With 2023 The ₩528.7bn operating-profit figure for January–September 2023 comes from press coverage that does not specify the consolidation basis. The ₩446.3bn for 2026 is Kiwoom's combined figure. The roughly ₩700bn excluding one-offs adds HYBE's approximate ₩255bn charge to ₩446.3bn.
- HYBE Operating-Profit Growth Kiwoom's table shows +254.3%; HYBE's filings imply roughly +260% because the nine-month 2025 base differs by several hundred million won. Figure 02-3 and the expandable calculations use Kiwoom's figures.
- Nov. 19 Share Prices The regular market closed at 4:30 p.m. for the national college entrance exam. Figure IN-2 uses those regular closes, not after-hours prices. Nov. 17–18 prices remain as the reference for the events.
- Age of Chinese Visitors Kiwoom describes 47% of additional Chinese arrivals as women aged 21–30, while the figure legend reads 21–40. This report uses the broader phrase “women in their twenties and thirties.”
- HYBE's Q3 Non-Operating Loss The ₩148.6bn figure is the difference between operating and pretax profit. The explanation that most came from revaluing foreign-currency cash is the company's.
- 2025 Album Exports The Korea Customs Service reported $301.74m (+3.4%); Kiwoom's series shows $322.46m. Figure 05-1 displays both.
- Yuanta's 2027 Forecast Its summary table totals ₩916.2bn for four agencies (JYP +3.7%), while summing its company-level data yields ₩927.4bn (JYP +4.9%). Figure 02-4 uses the company-level figures.
- Duty-Free Spending Per Buyer Foreign revenue divided by number of buyers. The January-to-September −28.9% compares months within the year; August's −22.4% is versus a year earlier.
- Concert-Tourist Spending The ₩3.53m comes from a government survey of foreign guests at a March Gwanghwamun concert. Kiwoom cites the Korea Tourism Organization. It should not be read as the average for all concert tourists.
Sources In order of first appearance
- E Today, “K-Content and Tourism Access Widens as South Korea–China FTA Follow-Up Talks Reach Substantial Conclusion,” Nov. 18, 2026 · etoday.co.kr
- Hankyung, “KOSPI Reclaims 5,000 on Nvidia Tailwind; Robotics and Entertainment Stocks Rally,” Nov. 18, 2026 · hankyung.com
- Yahoo Finance, “Daily Closing Prices: HYBE (352820.KS), SM (041510.KQ), JYP Ent. (035900.KQ), YG (122870.KQ) and KOSPI (^KS11),” accessed Nov. 18, 2026 · finance.yahoo.com
- Digital Daily, “South Korea–China FTA Talks Conclude as Hallyu Reopening Hopes Lift Entertainment Shares,” Nov. 18, 2026 · ddaily.co.kr
- Hankyung, “HYBE to Buy 50.1% of Japan's KeyHolder for ₩105.7bn,” Nov. 18, 2026 · hankyung.com
- Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism (Korea Policy Briefing), “South Korea Welcomes 20 Million Foreign Visitors for First Time,” Nov. 12, 2026 · korea.kr
- Seoul Shinmun, “Foreign Arrivals Top 20 Million as K-Culture Fuels Interest in Visiting Korea,” Nov. 12, 2026 · seoul.co.kr
- Kiwoom Securities, “2027 Entertainment & Leisure Outlook: Reasons for Optimism,” Nov. 17, 2026
- Asiae, “Four K-Pop Agencies Report ₩2.241tn in Q3 Revenue; HYBE Accounts for 68%,” Nov. 12, 2026 · view.asiae.co.kr
- Asiae, “K-Pop Agencies' Nine-Month Revenue Already Exceeds Last Year's Total,” Nov. 14, 2023 · view.asiae.co.kr
- SBS Biz, “HYBE Posts Record Results on BTS Momentum, Prepares Group and Solo Activities,” Nov. 3, 2026 · biz.sbs.co.kr
- MTN, “K-Pop Album Sales Seen Surpassing 100 Million Again,” Nov. 16, 2026 · news.mtn.co.kr
- Yuanta Securities, “Entertainment 2027: Building a Base for Recovery,” Nov. 12, 2026
- Asiae, “YG Posts ₩13.5bn in Q3 Operating Profit; Accelerates New-Group Debuts,” Nov. 9, 2026 · view.asiae.co.kr
- Sports Kyunghyang, “HYBE Hits Record Revenue but Net Profit Plunges 90%,” Nov. 4, 2026 · sports.khan.co.kr
- StockHub, “HYBE Q3 2026: Revenue Doubles, Parent-Shareholder Losses Continue,” Nov. 3, 2026 · stockhub.kr
- Herald Economy, “HYBE Posts ₩196.6bn Q1 Operating Loss Following One-Off Share-Compensation Expense,” Apr. 29, 2026 · heraldk.com
- CEO Score Daily, “Why HYBE Shares Fell Despite BTS Return and Record Earnings,” Sept. 2, 2026 · ceoscoredaily.com
- Money Today, “HYBE Hits 52-Week Low as FX Losses Shock Q3 Earnings,” Nov. 4, 2026 · mt.co.kr
- Asiae, “JYP Posts Record Q3 Revenue of ₩267.5bn; Operating Profit Up 17.6%,” Nov. 11, 2026 · view.asiae.co.kr
- Kyobo Securities, “Entertainment 2027: A Leap Beyond the Oceans,” Nov. 17, 2026
- The Korea Herald, “Annual Sales on Track to Surpass 100 Million Copies for the First Time in Three Years,” Nov. 1, 2026 · koreaherald.com
- Eugene Investment & Securities, “2027 Media, Entertainment & Leisure Outlook,” Nov. 12, 2026
- Hana Securities, “2027 Entertainment & Leisure Outlook: A Promising Odd-Numbered Year,” Nov. 11, 2026
- DS Investment & Securities, “2027 Industry Outlook: Food, Entertainment and Media—Emerging From the Tunnel,” Nov. 16, 2026
- Maeil Shinmun, “K-Pop Album Exports Hit Record in 2025 as Domestic Sales Fall for Second Year,” Jan. 16, 2026 · imaeil.com
- MTN, “SM Opens Its First Official K-Pop Merchandise Store in Shanghai,” May 7, 2026 · news.mtn.co.kr
- SK Securities, “Entertainment: FTA Breakthrough, a First Step Toward Concerts in China,” Nov. 19, 2026
- Hana Securities, “Entertainment, Media & Leisure: On Hopes for Easing Hallyu Restrictions,” Nov. 19, 2026
- Newsworks, “Presidential Office: More Channels Open for Discussing K-Pop Concert Permits in China,” Nov. 19, 2026 · newsworks.co.kr
- Newsis, “China Confirms Substantial Conclusion of FTA Phase-Two Talks, Citing Culture and Internet Cooperation,” Nov. 19, 2026 · newsis.com
- MTN, “Entertainment Stocks Extend Gains on FTA News as Studio Dragon Surges,” Nov. 19, 2026 · news.mtn.co.kr
- MyDaily, “Twenty Million Tourists, but Spending Shifts Away From Duty-Free Stores,” Nov. 16, 2026 · mydaily.co.kr
- Saturday Economy, “Government: Foreign Fans Spent ₩3.53m at BTS Concert, ₩1.08m More Than Average Tourists,” May 4, 2026 · sateconomy.co.kr
- Kiwoom Securities, “Cosmetics: Better China Ties Support the Sector,” Nov. 19, 2026
- Herald Economy, “Foreign Duty-Free Buyers Rise 39% as Spending Per Buyer Slumps,” Sept. 29, 2026 · biz.heraldcorp.com
- Hanwha Investment & Securities, “2027 Retail & Apparel Outlook,” Nov. 17, 2026
- Kiwoom Securities, “2027 Retail & Food Outlook: From Wealth Effects to Price Effects,” Nov. 17, 2026
- Yuanta Securities, “October Monthly Review: Three Foreigner-Only Casino Operators,” Nov. 12, 2026
- Financial News, “Medical Tourism Shifts From Plastic Surgery to Dermatology and Pharmacies,” Oct. 18, 2026 · fnnews.com
- IBK Investment & Securities, “The Future of K-Beauty Through Dermatology,” Oct. 22, 2026
- iM Securities, “Casino Sector Check: Tourism-Fund Uncertainty Is Key,” Oct. 23, 2026
- Digital Daily, “Casino Operators Warn Higher Fund Levies Could Cut Operating Profit by up to 28%,” July 21, 2026 · ddaily.co.kr
- Asiae, “Culture Ministry: Proposed 15% Casino Levy Would Not Apply Across All Revenue,” July 22, 2026 · view.asiae.co.kr
- Tax Accountant News, “Government Seeks Higher Casino Tourism-Fund Ceiling; Industry Calls It Punitive,” July 21, 2026 · webzine.kacta.or.kr
- MTN, “Casino Reform Delayed Until After Parliamentary Audit; GKL Marketing Costs Under Scrutiny,” Oct. 7, 2026 · news.mtn.co.kr
This report is for investment research and does not recommend buying or selling any security or product. Broker estimates and forecasts belong to their respective firms. Policy provisions are presented as reported facts, not endorsements.